Cica vs Panthenol: How to Compare Soothing Skincare Ingredients

Evidence mix: 10 sourcesLarge or systematic studies 9Medical societies & agencies 1Reviewed Next review See sourcesEvidence criteria

First decide whether your main concern is dryness and tightness or redness, then pick an ingredient that has been studied in that situation. That matches the evidence better than choosing by the word 'soothing.'

Three small bowls holding a centella leaf, a clear gel, and a white cream
In this article6 sections
  1. What are cica, centella, and panthenol?
  2. How do the research findings differ?
  3. How far does the “soothing” evidence go?
  4. Is a low concentration useless?
  5. Cica vs panthenol vs allantoin: comparison table
  6. When to see a dermatologist
Topic What the evidence says Source
Cica and centella Cica is a name for centella asiatica; centella extract, madecassoside, and asiaticoside are different raw materials Centella research summary
Centella and moisture 24 hours after one application of a product with hyaluronic acid 1%, glycerin 5%, and centella, skin hydration was 21% higher than a control site (20 healthy women) Centella research summary · A
Panthenol and the skin barrier On skin irritated with SLS, a dexpanthenol cream raised hydration and lowered redness more than the vehicle (base cream) Panthenol research summary · A
Allantoin on its own A 6% allantoin cream showed no significant difference from the vehicle on the primary endpoint in a phase 3 trial of 169 people with epidermolysis bullosa (a blistering skin disease) Allantoin research summary · A
Safety The CIR concluded panthenol is safe in cosmetics at current use levels; rare cases of contact allergy have been reported Panthenol research summary · Institution

What are cica, centella, and panthenol?

Cica and centella refer to the same plant, while panthenol and allantoin are separate ingredients. Centella products use several forms, such as centella extract, madecassoside, asiaticoside, and asiatic acid. Because each study used a different raw material, you can’t expect the same results just because something is called “cica research.”

Panthenol is related to pantothenic acid, and in studies it often appears under the name dexpanthenol. Allantoin mostly shows up in studies of products that mix it with other ingredients, such as scar gels. All three are described with the same word, “soothing,” but the situations in which they were studied are different.

Macro of a round centella leaf with visible veins and small water droplets
Cica and centella refer to the same plant, and products use several forms such as extract or madecassoside.

How do the research findings differ?

Centella research centers on multi-ingredient moisturizers, panthenol research on barrier measurements in irritated skin, and allantoin research on multi-ingredient scar gels. Most centella studies involve people with wounds or burns, oral extracts, or creams mixing several ingredients; studies comparing topical centella alone with a placebo over a long period in healthy people are rare. In 30 workers with dry hands, a centella cream improved hand hydration and pH after 4 weeks, and the ceramide cream it was compared with improved them too.

For panthenol, in a study of 60 people after laser procedures, the redness index on day 14 was 11.02 on the panthenol mask side versus 13.27 on the control side, and transepidermal water loss (TEWL) on day 7 was 12.63 versus 20.50. In 40 Asian people using acne medicine, a ceramide-and-panthenol moisturizer raised hydration and eased dryness more than a standard moisturizer. However, most of these were multi-ingredient products, so we can’t tell how much came from panthenol alone.

For allantoin, several studies found a scar gel containing it along with onion extract and heparin gave better surgical scar scores than no scar care, but none were placebo-controlled. A 6% cream containing only allantoin showed no significant difference from the vehicle on the primary endpoint in a trial of people with epidermolysis bullosa.

How far does the “soothing” evidence go?

For all three ingredients, it’s hard to find studies confirming they reduced redness or stinging compared with a placebo. The evidence on centella and redness comes only from a trial without a placebo group (75 women with sensitive skin; in the group that applied it, average facial redness fell 13% after 8 weeks compared with the start) and a trial where it was used together with an oral antibiotic. Whether panthenol eases symptoms you feel, like stinging or burning, is an open question, and there are no human studies comparing allantoin alone with a placebo for soothing or moisturizing. So in this article, we regard all three as moisturizing and barrier-care ingredients that people use hoping they will help calm the skin.

Tiny water droplets held beneath a thin film of clear gel on glass
This article regards all three as moisturizing and barrier-care ingredients that people use hoping they will help calm the skin.

Is a low concentration useless?

There is no evidence on whether effects change with concentration for any of the three. For panthenol, no evidence compares concentrations such as 1%, 2%, and 5%, and for centella, we can’t say whether amounts of madecassoside or asiaticoside make a difference. A rule like “below a certain ppm it does nothing” was not confirmed by this evidence. Before looking at the percentage, look at who it was tested on and in what form.

Cica vs panthenol vs allantoin: comparison table

Cica (centella) Panthenol Allantoin
Main situations studied People with wounds or burns, multi-ingredient moisturizers, oral extracts Irritated or post-procedure skin; skin on acne medicine Scar gels after surgery or tattoo removal (multi-ingredient products)
Results seen more than once Hydration and TEWL measures improved with multi-ingredient products Hydration, TEWL, and redness measures better than control Scar gel gave better scar scores than no scar care (not placebo)
Evidence for the ingredient alone Long-term placebo comparisons of topical centella alone are rare Only a few single-ingredient trials A 6% single-ingredient cream showed no difference on the primary endpoint
Redness and stinging No placebo-controlled studies No evidence on symptoms you feel No placebo-controlled studies
Safety notes Irritation index of 0 reported in a patch test of a centella-amla emulsion (not centella alone); sensitization rate unknown CIR safety conclusion; rare allergy cases No evidence on irritation or sensitization rates

When choosing, go through these steps.

  • Write down whether your biggest discomfort right now is dryness and tightness or redness.
  • Check the ingredient list to see whether the centella ingredient is an extract or a compound like madecassoside.
  • Add new products one at a time, and stop if itching or redness appears.
  • Every 2 to 4 weeks, note how dryness and redness have changed.
A small amount of white cream on the inner forearm with a fingertip just lifting away
Add new products one at a time, and stop if itching or redness appears.

When to see a dermatologist

  • If redness, itching, or swelling spreads after applying a product, or continues after you stop, consider seeing a dermatologist. Rare cases of contact allergy have been reported even with panthenol.
  • If redness and burning in the center of your face keep coming back for more than a few weeks, see a dermatologist, because it may need to be distinguished from other skin conditions.
  • If deep, painful acne keeps appearing, talk to a dermatologist rather than relying only on moisturizing or soothing products.

Frequently asked questions

Is cica the same as centella asiatica?

Yes, cica is a name for centella asiatica (gotu kola). But centella extract, madecassoside, and asiaticoside are different raw materials, so results from a study on one should not be applied as-is to another.

Cica or panthenol: which is better for breakout-prone skin?

We found no study that compared the two directly in breakout-prone skin. Panthenol has research on dryness in people using acne medicine, and centella is mostly studied in multi-ingredient moisturizers, so start by checking whether dryness and tightness are your main concern.

Do soothing ingredients work at low concentrations?

For both panthenol and centella, there is no evidence to answer whether effects change with concentration. Claims that an ingredient does nothing below a certain amount have not been confirmed by research either.

Can I use cica cream every day?

There isn't enough research on long-term daily use. Small studies reported few side effects, but how often centella causes contact allergy is not known, so stop using it if you notice itching or redness after applying.

Sources

  1. The 24-hour skin hydration and barrier function effects of a hyaluronic 1%, glycerin 5%, and Centella asiatica stem cells extract moisturizing fluid: an intra-subject, randomized, assessor-blinded study (PMID 28860834)A
  2. Optimized multiherbal combination and in vivo anti-skin aging potential: a randomized double blind placebo controlled study (PMID 37024608)A
  3. Role of Centella asiatica and ceramide in skin barrier improvement: a double blind clinical trial of Indonesian batik workers (2021, PMID 34214362)A
  4. Combining Topical and Oral Botanicals for Skin Redness, Pigmentation, Sleep, and Mood: A Randomized Controlled Study (2022, PMID 36431167)A
  5. The prophylactic use of a topical scar gel containing extract of Allium cepae, allantoin, and heparin improves symptoms and appearance of cesarean-section scars compared with untreated scars (2014, PMID 24509969)A
  6. Dexpanthenol enhances skin barrier repair and reduces inflammation after sodium lauryl sulphate-induced irritation (PMID 19753737)A
  7. Evaluation of the Efficacy and Safety of a Panthenol-Enriched Mask for Skin Barrier Recovery After Facial Laser Treatment: Results of a Double-Blind Randomized Controlled Study (PMID 40613435)A
  8. The efficacy of a bioactive moisturizer in mitigating side effects of acne therapies: a randomized, investigator-blind, split-face trial (PMID 41891349)A
  9. Efficacy and tolerability of the investigational topical cream SD-101 (6% allantoin) in patients with epidermolysis bullosa: a phase 3, randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled trial (ESSENCE study) (PMID 32576219)A
  10. CIR — Safety Assessment of Panthenol, Pantothenic Acid, and Derivatives as Used in CosmeticsInstitutional

We never use YouTube videos or community posts as evidence for facts. Editorial policy

Product information related to this article

Product information from the site operator (KW Cosmetic, maker of the SKIN9HARI brand).

Centella Rescue Spot Ampoule

₩22,000 (KRW)

  • Ampoule with alcohol-extracted Centella asiatica extract as the main ingredient, 15 ml
  • Also contains Aloe Phytoplacenta, Greenol and Campanula callus extract
  • Contains alcohol, so it may sting; try it on a small area first
  • Low-irritation formula

Product details

Type and size
Fast-absorbing gel ampoule, 15 mL (0.5 fl oz)
Step in routine
Spot care, layered any time
How to use
Use the dropper to apply a small amount directly to the area of concern. Pat gently until absorbed. Layer it at any step of your routine — before or after your regular toner, ampoule, or cream.
Before you use
Contains ethanol and natural bergamot oil, which may cause a slight tingling sensation on very sensitive or freshly irritated skin — patch test first if unsure. If redness, swelling or itching occurs, stop using and consult a dermatologist.

Based on the official product page, checked 2026-10-02

View in shop

Cosmetics do not diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Test results apply only to the stated conditions.