Skincare for Closed Comedones: 5 Habits Instead of Squeezing
Closed comedones are clogged pores with a closed opening, so squeezing is not the answer. Expert groups point to gentle cleansing, products that don't clog pores, and 6 to 8 weeks of steady care.

In this article8 sections
- Should you pop closed comedones or leave them alone?
- How should you wash your face?
- How to screen out pore-clogging creams, lotions, and makeup
- Should you exfoliate closed comedones?
- What are comedolytics, and how are they different from skincare ingredients?
- How long before you can tell if it’s working?
- Closed comedones care checklist
- When to see a dermatologist
| Topic | What the evidence says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| What they are | The tiny bumps often called closed comedones are usually whiteheads: pores clogged with oil and dead skin cells, with the opening closed over | Comedones · Institutions (AAD) |
| Squeezing | The NHS and AAD advise against squeezing blackheads and whiteheads. Squeezing is one of the risk factors for scarring | Squeezing and picking · Institutions · A |
| How long to wait | Give one approach 6 to 8 weeks, and consider a dermatologist if they are still there (AAD) | Comedones · Institutions |
| Low-strength salicylic acid | Only one trial we reviewed compared a low-strength product with salicylic acid alone against its vehicle. It lasted 5 days and found no difference | Salicylic acid · A |
| Noncomedogenic labels | Expert groups recommend them, but the label itself is not a standard managed by regulators | Comedogenicity · A |
Should you pop closed comedones or leave them alone?
Expert groups agree you should not squeeze closed comedones, and there is also no evidence that they disappear within a few days if you leave them. The NHS explains that squeezing blackheads and whiteheads can make them worse and leave permanent scars. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) says squeezing, picking, or scratching raises the risk of inflammation, infection, and dark marks.
Instead of squeezing, focus on everyday habits that may mean fewer new ones form. The AAD suggests considering extraction or prescription options at a dermatologist’s office if whiteheads and blackheads are still there after 6 to 8 weeks. The AAD also makes it clear that squeezing at home and extraction at a clinic are different, because the tools and conditions are different.

How should you wash your face?
Wash up to twice a day with lukewarm water and a mild cleanser, using your fingertips gently. The NHS says not to wash more than twice a day, and the AAD says washing too often or scrubbing can irritate skin and make things worse. The AAD specifically advises against scrubbing blackheads.
There is also a study on how often to wash. In a trial that split men with acne into groups washing 1, 2, or 4 times a day, the twice-a-day group had fewer open comedones and non-inflamed lesions, and the once-a-day group had more inflamed lesions. But the overall differences between groups were not statistically significant. There is little reason to stray far from the twice-a-day advice.
How to screen out pore-clogging creams, lotions, and makeup
NICE, the AAD, and the NHS all advise choosing skin care, makeup, and hair products labeled oil-free or noncomedogenic. However, a review of studies from 1985 to 2017 found that labels such as noncomedogenic and oil-free are not managed by regulators and are used inconsistently. Human testing of whether individual ingredients form comedones on the face is limited to a few studies, such as occlusive patch tests on the back.
So look at the label and at how your own skin responds. The AAD explains that acne caused by cosmetics can appear anywhere from a few days to 6 months after you start a product. Add new products one at a time, and if your closed comedones cluster on your forehead, check the oils in your hair products too. Taking off makeup before bed is another point the AAD stresses again and again.

Should you exfoliate closed comedones?
The evidence that closed comedones require exfoliation is weak. If you do exfoliate, avoid scrubbing, start at a low frequency, and watch for irritation. The AAD advises avoiding harsh products such as astringents and exfoliants, as well as scrubs. At the same time, the AAD notes that salicylic acid is an active ingredient in some over-the-counter acne medicines.
The salicylic acid evidence needs to be read by strength. The clearest drops in comedone counts came mostly from 20% to 30% salicylic acid peels, which are done in a clinic, not at home. Only one trial we reviewed compared a low-strength product containing salicylic acid alone with its vehicle; it lasted 5 days and found no difference. The EU’s SCCS considers salicylic acid used for purposes other than preservation to be safe at up to 3.0% in rinse-off hair products and 2.0% in most other products, with lower limits for some product types.
What are comedolytics, and how are they different from skincare ingredients?
“Comedolytic” is a term for ingredients that work to loosen clogged comedones, and the strongest evidence for reducing comedones comes from prescription topical retinoids. The German acne guideline also names topical retinoids as a first choice for comedone-dominant acne. These are medicines, so whether to use them is decided with a doctor, and those results should not be carried over to cosmetic retinol.
The evidence on the cosmetic side is small. Most studies of salicylic acid or LHA formulas, or of finished products that mix several ingredients, involve a few dozen people using them for 15 days to 12 weeks, and a low-strength product with salicylic acid alone was no different from its vehicle. So when you pick a cream or lotion for closed comedones, look past names like “comedolytic” and check first whether it avoids clogging pores and whether it stings or dries your skin.
How long before you can tell if it’s working?
The AAD advises sticking with one approach for 6 to 8 weeks before judging it. But if stinging or swelling starts or gets worse, stop without waiting. The AAD explains that switching products every week can irritate skin and cause new breakouts, and that it can take 3 to 4 months to see a noticeable change. For acne medicine, the same organization advises applying a thin layer over the whole area where you tend to break out, rather than only on the bumps you see.

Closed comedones care checklist
| What to check | Standard | Check |
|---|---|---|
| Did you avoid squeezing or picking? | Don’t squeeze (NHS, AAD) | □ |
| Do you wash no more than twice a day? | Morning, night, and after sweating (AAD) | □ |
| Do you wash gently with lukewarm water and your fingertips? | Avoid scrubbing and scrubs (AAD) | □ |
| Are your skin care, makeup, and hair products labeled oil-free or noncomedogenic? | NICE, AAD, NHS | □ |
| Did you add new products one at a time? | Reactions can show up late (AAD) | □ |
| Did you start acid pads or serums at a low frequency? | Increase only if there is no stinging or dryness | □ |
| Did you take off your makeup before bed? | AAD | □ |
| Have you kept the same routine for 6 to 8 weeks? | Don’t switch every week (AAD) | □ |
When to see a dermatologist
- If your closed comedones stay the same or increase after 6 to 8 weeks of the same routine, consider seeing a dermatologist.
- If they often turn into red, swollen, or painful pus-filled pimples, have a dermatologist check your skin.
- If what looks like a closed comedone is a hard white bump that has not changed shape for months, it may be a different skin condition that looks like acne, so have a dermatologist tell them apart.
- If squeezing or picking has started to leave marks or pits, talk to a dermatologist.
Frequently asked questions
How do you get rid of closed comedones on your face?
No evidence shows a method that makes closed comedones disappear within days. What expert groups recommend are everyday habits that mean fewer new ones form, and these habits may help you manage them. The AAD, NHS, and NICE agree: wash gently with a mild cleanser up to twice a day, don't squeeze or scrub, and choose oil-free, noncomedogenic moisturizers and makeup. If nothing changes or things get worse after 6 to 8 weeks of the same routine, consider seeing a dermatologist.
Should you pop closed comedones?
No. Expert groups agree you should not squeeze them. The NHS explains that squeezing blackheads and whiteheads can make them worse and leave permanent scars, and the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) suggests considering extraction or prescription options at a dermatologist's office if they are still there after 6 to 8 weeks.
How long do closed comedones last if you leave them alone?
We found no evidence on how long they take to go away on their own or what happens if you simply wait. What is clear is that you should not squeeze or pick them. The AAD says squeezing and picking raise the risk of inflammation, infection, and dark marks.
Why won't my closed comedones go away?
Changing your routine too often makes it hard to judge. The AAD suggests giving one approach 6 to 8 weeks, notes that switching products every week can irritate skin and cause new breakouts, and explains that acne caused by cosmetics can show up as late as 6 months after you start a product.
What's the best way to wash your face with closed comedones?
Wash up to twice a day with lukewarm water and a mild cleanser, using your fingertips. The AAD says washing too often or scrubbing can irritate skin and make things worse, and it specifically advises against scrubbing blackheads.
Can you manage closed comedones with skincare alone?
The AAD says mild acne such as whiteheads and blackheads can often be managed at home. The same organization says to consider seeing a dermatologist if nothing changes after 6 to 8 weeks of one approach.
Should you exfoliate closed comedones every day?
There is no evidence that daily exfoliation is better. The AAD advises avoiding scrubs and harsh exfoliants, so if you use pads with acids, it is safer to start with a low frequency and increase only if you have no dryness or stinging.
Is a noncomedogenic label enough?
Expert groups do recommend noncomedogenic products, but a literature review notes the label is not a standard managed by regulators. Add new products one at a time and track for a few weeks whether your closed comedones increase. That is the most practical check.
Sources
- AAD — What's that blemish? (updated 2023-09-12)Institutional
- AAD — 10 skin care habits that can worsen acneInstitutional
- AAD — Acne: Tips for managing (2022)Institutional
- NHS — Acne (reviewed 2026-09-22)Institutional
- NHS 111 Wales — Health A-Z: Acne (updated 2024-11-07)Institutional
- Clinical utility of marketing terms used for over-the-counter dermatologic products (2018, PMID 29671667)A
- A single-blinded, randomized, controlled clinical trial evaluating the effect of face washing on acne vulgaris (2006, PMID 17014635)A
- Five-day study to judge the short-term effect of a benzoyl peroxide 3% gel on acne lesions (2016, PMID 27489202)A
- SCCS — Opinion on salicylic acid (CAS 69-72-7) - Submission I (SCCS/1601/18)Institutional
- S2k guideline for therapy of acne, German Dermatological Society (2010, PMID 20579226)A
We never use YouTube videos or community posts as evidence for facts. Editorial policy
Product information related to this article
Product information from the site operator (KW Cosmetic, maker of the SKIN9HARI brand).
Revive Therapy N.F Toner
₩29,000 (KRW)
- Mildly acidic toner (pH 5.5–6.5), 150 ml
- Contains niacinamide 2.0% and beta-glucan 1.0%
- Low-irritation formula
- Contains ethanol and fragrance ingredients (orange peel oil, lavender oil); check the full ingredient list
Product details
- Type and size
- Clear, water-light toner, pH 5.5–6.5, 150 mL (5.07 fl oz)
- Step in routine
- Step 2 of 4 · Tone, right after cleansing
- How to use
- After cleansing, pour a small amount onto a cotton pad or your palms. Sweep or press gently over your face and neck. Pat lightly until fully absorbed. Follow with Revive Therapy N.F Ampoule, then N.F Cream.
- Before you use
- Contains ethanol (3.0%) and fragrance, including the allergens linalool and limonene — this is not an alcohol-free formula. If redness, swelling or itching occurs, stop using and consult a dermatologist.
Based on the official product page, checked 2026-10-02
Cosmetics do not diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Test results apply only to the stated conditions.


