---
title: "Acne Marks vs Scars: Red Marks, Dark Spots, Dents, and Causes"
description: "Acne marks vs scars: why scars form, who gets them, how they differ from red marks and brown spots, how dermatologists approach them, and when to see one."
url: https://thetroublenote.com/en/type/acne-marks-vs-scars/
markdown: https://thetroublenote.com/en/type/acne-marks-vs-scars.md
language: en
site: "TroubleNote"
publisher: "KW Cosmetic Content Team"
author: "KW Cosmetic Content Team"
section: "Types"
keywords: ["acne marks vs scars", "acne scars", "acne scars vs hyperpigmentation", "types of acne scars", "red acne marks", "post inflammatory hyperpigmentation acne", "acne scars vs pie", "do acne scars go away", "why do acne scars form", "how to prevent acne scars", "atrophic acne scars", "acne scars on back", "types of acne scars on nose"]
published: 2026-09-26
updated: 2026-09-28
evidence: "Mixed · Evidence across several grades"
image: https://thetroublenote.com/images/acne-marks-vs-scars/acne-marks-vs-scars-cover.jpg
alternates:
  ko: https://thetroublenote.com/type/acne-marks-vs-scars.md
  vi: https://thetroublenote.com/vi/type/acne-marks-vs-scars.md
  th: https://thetroublenote.com/th/type/acne-marks-vs-scars.md
  tl: https://thetroublenote.com/tl/type/acne-marks-vs-scars.md
  ja: https://thetroublenote.com/ja/type/acne-marks-vs-scars.md
---

# Acne Marks vs Scars: Red Marks, Dark Spots, Dents, and Causes

> An acne scar is a change in the skin's shape, either sunken or raised. That makes it different from a flat post-acne mark, where only the color has changed.

Acne marks vs scars: why scars form, who gets them, how they differ from red marks and brown spots, how dermatologists approach them, and when to see one.

![Two stones on rose-colored paper, one smooth and one with a slight dip on top](https://thetroublenote.com/images/acne-marks-vs-scars/acne-marks-vs-scars-cover.jpg)

| Type | Surface | Color and shape | Over time | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Red mark | Flat | Pink or reddish | Described as a color change that fades | AAD · 2024 RCT (A) |
| Brown mark | Flat | Brown or dark spot | Fades, but the darker it is, the longer it takes | AAD guidance |
| Sunken scar | Dips in | Icepick, boxcar, rolling, and more | Rarely disappears completely on its own | AAD · Acne scar research summary (A) |
| Raised scar | Raised above the surrounding skin | Keloids and more | Risk mentioned for darker skin | AAD guidance |

## Flat or sunken: what is the difference between an acne mark and a scar?

The first way to tell marks from scars is not color but the shape of the skin's surface. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) explains that completely flat pink, red, purple, black, or brown spots left where acne healed are not scars but post-inflammatory color changes. These spots are often mistaken for permanent scars, but the AAD says they fade on their own over time, and the darker the spot, the longer it takes. Scars, on the other hand, may soften but rarely disappear completely on their own.

So if the skin feels smooth when you run a fingertip over it and only color is left, it leans toward a mark. If the surface has changed, sunken or raised, it leans toward a scar. Color and a dip can show up in the same spot, so if it's hard to tell, a dermatologist can give you a more accurate answer.

![A fingertip lightly brushing across a cheek in window light](https://thetroublenote.com/images/acne-marks-vs-scars/acne-marks-vs-scars-1.jpg)
*Whether the skin feels smooth or sunken under your fingertip is the first way to tell a mark from a scar.*

## Why do acne scars form, and who is more likely to get them?

Acne scars mostly form after deep acne settles down, and not every pimple leaves a scar. The AAD says scar risk is higher with deep, painful acne, a family history of scarring, and habits of squeezing, picking, or scratching. It also explains that the risk goes up the longer acne lasts without proper care or stays poorly controlled.

Research points to similar factors. A self-assessment tool for atrophic (sunken) scar risk was built on four factors: peak acne severity, how long acne lasted, family history of scarring, and squeezing or picking. It had 82% sensitivity and 43% specificity (grade A). Because specificity is low, it has limits in predicting any one person's scars. In a survey of 225 Thai patients with acne, acne severity, squeezing or picking, and having had red marks after acne came out as factors linked to scarring (grade B, cross-sectional survey).

So the key to fewer scars is dealing early with the acne that is coming up now, more than with scars that have already formed. Canadian guidelines concluded that the most effective way to deal with scars is to keep them from forming in the first place (grade A), and the AAD also recommends seeing a board-certified dermatologist for deep, painful acne.

## How do you tell red acne marks from brown hyperpigmentation?

Red marks and brown marks are both flat color changes, but research measures them separately with different indicators. A randomized controlled trial that followed 72 people with acne for 12 weeks separated red marks as post-inflammatory erythema (PIE) and brown marks as post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH), and measured hemoglobin and melanin levels for each (grade A). But the AAD's patient guidance groups pink, red, and brown spots together as color changes, not scars.

How long color lingers is also related to skin tone. The AAD says dark spots after acne tend to linger in darker skin tones, and in a review of studies on hyperpigmentation after acne, almost every study recommended using sunscreen with SPF 30 or higher (grade A). We cover how long red marks take to fade separately in [how long acne marks take to fade](https://thetroublenote.com/en/qna/how-long-acne-marks-fade/).

![A distant view of a woman in a wide-brimmed hat walking in the shade of trees on a clear day](https://thetroublenote.com/images/acne-marks-vs-scars/acne-marks-vs-scars-3.jpg)
*Most studies on hyperpigmentation after acne recommended using sunscreen with SPF 30 or higher.*

## What are the types of sunken acne scars?

Sunken scars are named by shape as icepick, boxcar, and rolling scars, and each type has been reported to respond differently to procedures. In a review of acne scar studies, non-ablative fractional methods worked better on rolling and boxcar scars and less well on icepick scars (grade A). Almost all of these were studies of dermatology procedures, such as laser, needling, and injection-based procedures.

The quality of the evidence also has limits. A Cochrane review concluded that the evidence in most acne scar studies is very low quality, and that only one injection-based filling procedure had shown an effect compared with placebo (grade A). The sources we reviewed had no confirmed evidence that applying cosmetic skincare alone changes scars that are already sunken.

![A narrow deep groove, a flat-bottomed groove, and a gently wavy groove side by side on a smooth clay surface](https://thetroublenote.com/images/acne-marks-vs-scars/acne-marks-vs-scars-4.jpg)
*Sunken scars are named by shape as icepick, boxcar, and rolling scars.*

## Should you judge scars on the back, nose, or chin the same way?

Even in different areas, the first thing to check is the same: is it a flat color change, or is it sunken or raised? In a study of 973 people with acne that created a scale for rating scars on the face, chest, and back together, 73% said they had scars, which shows scarring is not just a face problem (grade B). But our sources had no study comparing how often scars form, or what shape they take, by body area.

Keep in mind that the trunk is an area people get checked less often. In a survey of 211 high school students in Incheon, Korea, 17.6% had seen a doctor for acne on the trunk, lower than 48.6% for the face (grade B). If deep, painful acne keeps coming back on your back or chest, getting care early, just as with the face, is the starting point for fewer scars. We cover the causes of back and chest breakouts in [back acne](https://thetroublenote.com/en/cause/back-acne-causes/).

## How do dermatologists approach acne scars?

For scars that have already formed, a dermatologist decides on an approach based on the scar's shape, depth, and your skin tone, and the pain, recovery time, and level of evidence differ by approach. The acne scar studies we reviewed are mostly split-face trials with 10 to 60 people, and one review found that combining several methods generally did better than using just one (grade A). A pattern repeated across studies: methods with bigger effects tended to bring more pain, longer scabbing and redness, and a higher risk of dark spots after the procedure.

Age and how long you have had the scar also matter. In a study of 60 people with atrophic scars, older people and older scars improved less (grade A). If you have a darker skin tone, procedures carry a risk of permanent color changes, so, as the AAD advises, it is safer to talk to a dermatologist with a lot of experience treating skin of color. The method, number of sessions, and cost can't be set from our sources, so decide them in consultation with your doctor.

## How do you tell hyperpigmentation from melasma, sunspots, or moles?

Melasma, sunspots (lentigines), and moles are different pigment conditions studied separately from hyperpigmentation after acne, and our sources had no criteria for telling them apart at home. The clearest clue is that an acne mark stays in the exact spot where the pimple was. Don't judge for yourself a spot that appeared where you never had acne, or any mark or mole that darkens or changes shape; have a dermatologist check it.

![A still life of a small notebook and pencil on a desk, with a hand writing a date](https://thetroublenote.com/images/acne-marks-vs-scars/acne-marks-vs-scars-2.jpg)
*Writing down the date you first noticed it and its current color makes it easier to compare whether it is fading.*

## Log: sort your mark into one of three types

| What to check | Record | How to read it |
|---|---|---|
| Does the surface feel smooth when you run a fingertip over it? | Smooth / sunken / raised | Smooth usually points to a mark; sunken or raised points to a scar (texture alone can't confirm it) |
| What is the color closest to? | Pink or reddish / brown or dark / skin-colored | Tells red marks from brown marks |
| Is it the exact spot where you had a pimple? | Yes / No | If no, it could be a different pigment condition |
| Date you first noticed it and how dark it is now | Date and photo | Compare whether it is fading |
| Did you squeeze or pick that spot? | Yes / No | Squeezing and picking raise scar risk (AAD) |

## When to see a dermatologist

- If you have scars where the surface is sunken or raised, talk to a board-certified dermatologist to decide on an approach.
- If deep, painful acne keeps appearing, see a dermatologist before scars form. The AAD and Canadian guidelines see early care as the key to lowering scar risk.
- Have a dermatologist check any spot where you never had acne, or any mark or mole that darkens or changes shape.
- If you have a darker skin tone and are considering a procedure, talk to a dermatologist with a lot of experience treating skin of color, as the AAD advises.

## Frequently asked questions

### What are the types of acne scars?

First, separate color changes with a flat surface (red marks and brown spots) from scars where the skin's shape has changed. Sunken scars are named by shape as icepick, boxcar, and rolling scars, and each type has been reported to respond differently to dermatology procedures.

### Do acne scars go away on their own?

The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) says flat color changes left where acne healed fade on their own over time, and the darker the spot, the longer it takes. In contrast, it explains that sunken or raised scars may soften but rarely disappear completely on their own.

### Why do acne scars form?

They mostly form after deep acne settles down. The AAD says scar risk is higher with deep, painful acne, a family history of scarring, and habits of squeezing, picking, or scratching. A scar risk assessment tool was also built on four factors: severity, how long acne lasted, family history, and squeezing.

### How can you prevent acne scars?

Canadian guidelines concluded that the most effective way to deal with scars is to keep them from forming in the first place. The starting point is not squeezing or picking, and, as the AAD recommends, seeing a board-certified dermatologist early for deep, painful acne.

### Are red marks and brown marks different? What is PIE vs PIH?

Research measures red marks after acne (post-inflammatory erythema, PIE) and brown marks after acne (post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, PIH) separately. But the AAD's patient guidance groups pink, red, and brown flat spots together as color changes, not scars.

### Can sunken acne scars improve with at-home care?

Our sources had no evidence confirming that applying cosmetic skincare alone, without a procedure, changes sunken scars that have already formed. Most acne scar research studies dermatology procedures, so it is better to decide on an approach for sunken scars with a dermatologist.

## Sources

- [AAD, Acne: Signs and symptoms](https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne/really-acne/symptoms) — Institutional
- [AAD, Acne scars: Diagnosis and treatment](https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne/derm-treat/scars) — Institutional
- [AAD, Acne in skin of color](https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne/diy/skin-color) — Institutional
- [Interventions for acne scars (Cochrane review, 2016, PMID 27038134)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27038134/) — A
- [A systematic review of treatments for acne scarring. Part 2: Energy-based techniques (2018, PMID 30627441)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30627441/) — A
- [Effects of 15% azelaic acid gel in the management of post-inflammatory erythema and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation in acne vulgaris (2024, PMID 38734843)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38734843/) — A
- [Topical treatment for postinflammatory hyperpigmentation: a systematic review (2022, PMID 34525885)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34525885/) — A
- [Development of an atrophic acne scar risk assessment tool (2017, PMID 28499079)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28499079/) — A
- [Acne scarring management: Systematic review and evaluation of the evidence (2018, PMID 29744784)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29744784/) — A
- [Microneedling (Dermapen) and Jessner's solution peeling in treatment of atrophic acne scars: a comparative randomized clinical study (2019, PMID 31495242)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31495242/) — A
- [Risk factors associated with facial acne scarring in Thai patients with acne: A cross-sectional study (2025, PMID 39601200)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39601200/) — B
- [Treatment of acne vulgaris and prevention of acne scarring: Canadian consensus guidelines (2000, PMID 11749902)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11749902/) — A
- [Development and validation of a Scale for Acne Scar Severity (SCAR-S) of the face and trunk (2010, PMID 20642983)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20642983/) — B
- [Beyond the face: An exploratory survey on facial and truncal acne in high school students (2026, PMID 41942377)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41942377/) — B

## Product information related to this article

Product information from the site operator (KW Cosmetic, maker of the SKIN9HARI brand).

**Revive Therapy N.F Ampoule** — ₩31,000 (KRW)

Apart from the skin changes and dermatology care discussed here, this is a factual note on one cosmetic used daily after toner. Revive Therapy N.F Ampoule is a 30 ml ampoule with betaine and panthenol, free of added fragrance and ethanol per its full ingredient list, and patch-tested for irritation, yet it has not been tested on any of the states this article sorts. Its product page places it after toner and before cream, and it is not for broken skin. It is a cosmetic, not a medicine; if the skin surface has sunk or risen, or you use a prescription, see a dermatologist first.

- Ampoule with vegan rice PDRN (listed as Sodium DNA), betaine and panthenol, 30 ml
- No added fragrance, essential oils, ethanol, colorants or silicones (based on the full ingredient list)
- Low-irritation formula

### Product details

- **Type and size**: Clear, lightweight ampoule, 30 mL (1.01 fl oz)
- **Step in routine**: Step 3 of 4 · Ampoule, after toner and before cream
- **How to use**: After toner, use the dropper to dispense 2–3 drops into your palm or directly onto your face. Press gently into skin until absorbed. Follow with Revive Therapy N.F Cream to seal in moisture.
- **Before you use**: Patch test on your inner arm before first use if you have very reactive skin. If redness, swelling or itching occurs, stop using and consult a dermatologist.

_Based on the official product page, checked 2026-10-02_

[View in shop](https://skin9hari.co.kr/en/shop/)

Cosmetics do not diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Test results apply only to the stated conditions.

---

TroubleNote is run by KW Cosmetic Content Team. Articles on this site are general information and do not replace diagnosis or medical care. If your symptoms are severe or last a long time, consider seeing a dermatologist.

Written by KW Cosmetic Content Team · Last updated 2026-09-28 · https://thetroublenote.com/en/type/acne-marks-vs-scars/
