---
title: "Niacinamide Benefits vs Hyaluronic Acid and Panthenol: Need Both?"
description: "Niacinamide benefits vs hyaluronic acid and panthenol: what each set of studies measured, on whose skin, and how to decide on another serum from the label."
url: https://thetroublenote.com/en/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/
markdown: https://thetroublenote.com/en/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured.md
language: en
site: "TroubleNote"
publisher: "KW Cosmetic Content Team"
author: "KW Cosmetic Content Team"
section: "How to Choose"
keywords: ["niacinamide benefits", "niacinamide vs hyaluronic acid", "niacinamide and hyaluronic acid together", "niacinamide and panthenol", "hyaluronic acid serum vs niacinamide serum", "dexpanthenol and niacinamide cream", "niacinamide serum difference", "moisturizing ingredients compared"]
published: 2026-11-20
updated: 2026-11-20
evidence: "Mixed · Evidence across several grades"
image: https://thetroublenote.com/images/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured-cover.jpg
alternates:
  ko: https://thetroublenote.com/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured.md
  vi: https://thetroublenote.com/vi/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured.md
  th: https://thetroublenote.com/th/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured.md
  tl: https://thetroublenote.com/tl/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured.md
  ja: https://thetroublenote.com/ja/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured.md
---

# Niacinamide Benefits vs Hyaluronic Acid and Panthenol: Need Both?

> Niacinamide benefits come from studies that looked at different skin and took different readings than hyaluronic acid and panthenol studies, so research cannot rank them, and no human study has compared all three side by side.

Niacinamide benefits vs hyaluronic acid and panthenol: what each set of studies measured, on whose skin, and how to decide on another serum from the label.

![Two clear water droplets side by side and one white petal on a glass table by a window in the morning](https://thetroublenote.com/images/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured-cover.jpg)

| Topic | What we know | Evidence level |
|---|---|---|
| Hyaluronic acid on the skin | Randomized trials in which healthy people applied creams or lotions mostly had 20–80 participants, and higher hydration readings after use were reported several times. Many of the trials with good results used finished products blended with other ingredients or special formulations | Several small RCTs · moderate |
| Panthenol (dexpanthenol) | Most studies looked at skin that was deliberately irritated, skin damaged by procedures or medicines, or finished products mixing several ingredients. In a placebo-controlled trial of dexpanthenol 5%, 21 of 25 people finished, and the only reading with a statistically significant difference was stratum corneum hydration | 2003 PMID 14641355 · A |
| Niacinamide | Single-ingredient trials mostly used 2–5%, a few dozen participants and 4–12 weeks, and more than half of the linked studies were finished products with other ingredients or were run alongside prescription medicines or procedures | Many RCTs · large share of blended studies |
| A product with both ingredients | It was applied to one shin of 35 people for 28 days while the other shin was left bare, so with no comparison against a base without the actives, the authors wrote that the effect could not be credited to any one ingredient | 2026 PMID 42108609 · A |
| Direct comparison of all three | No human trial has compared the three ingredients within one trial on healthy skin, and the only comparisons of hyaluronic acid with other moisturizing ingredients come from patient studies | No evidence |

## Niacinamide benefits vs hyaluronic acid and panthenol: can one scale compare them?

Niacinamide benefits, as they are usually described, and the roles of hyaluronic acid and panthenol come from studies that measured different things on different skin under different conditions, so you cannot say one is better than another. In the sources reviewed for this article, not a single human trial compared the three ingredients in the same people, over the same period, with the same measurements. That makes "which one works better?" a question current research cannot answer.

Hyaluronic acid studies mostly looked at skin hydration readings, panthenol studies mostly looked at hydration and water-loss readings on damaged skin, and niacinamide studies took a range of readings, including barrier-related ones. The people studied also varied: healthy adults, forearm skin that was irritated on purpose, skin after a procedure, dry skin on the legs. If you already use a hyaluronic acid serum or a panthenol cream, decide on a niacinamide serum by checking the label for what is listed on its own and what is blended in, and bring products in one at a time so any reaction is easier to read later.

## Hyaluronic acid serum: who did the studies test, and what did they measure?

The result that keeps coming up for hyaluronic acid applied to the skin is that hydration readings went up after use, and the randomized controlled trials in which healthy people applied creams or lotions were small, mostly 20–80 people. In the material gathered for this article, the largest group of hyaluronic acid studies involved injections, followed by medical settings such as wounds and burns and by oral supplements, so studies of skincare applied to the skin are relatively few. Many trials with good results used finished products or special formulations that also contained other ingredients such as glycerin or centella, which makes it hard to speak of hyaluronic acid's share on its own.

The sources include no sizable trial that compared hyaluronic acid alone, at a normal cosmetic level, with a base for more than three months. They also cannot tell you whether results differ for oily, sensitive or breakout-prone skin, or in low humidity, and no study put it head to head with panthenol or niacinamide under the same conditions. In its 2023 final assessment, the US Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) concluded that seven hyaluronates, including hyaluronic acid and sodium hyaluronate, are safe in cosmetics in the present practices of use and concentration, but that is a safety assessment, not data that measured results on skin. Oral products, injections and molecular weight are covered separately in [hyaluronic acid benefits](https://thetroublenote.com/en/ingredient/hyaluronic-acid/).

![The hand of a woman in her late 20s in front of a sink, looking at a single drop of clear serum on the back of her hand](https://thetroublenote.com/images/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured-1.jpg)
*Most trials of hyaluronic acid applied to the skin had 20–80 people, and many results came from finished products blended with other ingredients.*

## Why are most panthenol studies about damaged skin?

Most panthenol (dexpanthenol) studies took hydration, water-loss and redness readings on skin that was already damaged: skin irritated on purpose, skin after a procedure, or skin of people using medicines. Only a handful tested panthenol by itself; the rest were finished products that mixed it with ingredients such as niacinamide, ceramides or centella. The sources include no grade A trial that compared panthenol alone with a placebo over a long period on healthy, everyday skin, and no human study that put it head to head with hyaluronic acid or niacinamide.

As an example of a single-ingredient trial, a 2003 placebo-controlled, double-blind study had 25 healthy volunteers (aged 18–45) apply a dexpanthenol 5% product and a placebo to the inner side of both forearms twice a day for 26 days. From day 15 to day 22, the same spots also got the cleansing agent SLS 2% to irritate them on purpose, and among the 21 people who finished, the only reading with a statistically significant difference was stratum corneum hydration. Because this was an arm-irritation setup, it is hard to carry over to applying something to your face every day, and current data cannot show how results change when the panthenol level is 1%, 2% or 5%.

CIR considers panthenol, pantothenic acid and five other derivatives safe as cosmetic ingredients at current use levels, while noting that, because of residual amine impurities, they should not go into formulations where N-nitroso compounds could form. There are also rare case reports of contact allergy, so there is no basis for calling it an ingredient that never causes allergies. Name differences such as dexpanthenol and D-panthenol are laid out in the [panthenol cream](https://thetroublenote.com/en/ingredient/panthenol-cream/) article.

## Niacinamide on its own vs in blended products: how do the studies split?

There are several human trials in which people applied niacinamide on its own, but the level was mostly 2–5%, participants numbered a few dozen and the period was 4–12 weeks, and more than half of the linked studies were finished products with other ingredients or were run alongside prescription medicines or procedures. Studies of patients with skin conditions also make up a large share, so it is hard to carry their results over as the effect of the ingredient alone on healthy skin. The studies took a range of readings, starting with barrier-related ones such as water loss (TEWL), and none of them compared niacinamide with hyaluronic acid or panthenol under the same conditions either.

As an example of a blended-product study, a 2015 double-blind trial had 40 women aged 40–70 apply a complex of gold silk sericin, niacinamide and Signaline to one side of the face and a base to the other side for 8 weeks. It measured several readings, including stratum corneum hydration and barrier function, but because the three ingredients were combined in one formula, niacinamide's share remains unknown, which stands as a limit of this study. Studies on breakout-prone skin and responses at different levels are covered separately in the [niacinamide research summary](https://thetroublenote.com/en/ingredient/niacinamide-acne/).

It is also hard to state that niacinamide stings no one. In the 2010 lotion trial described below, a burning feeling was reported as an adverse event, and the results of cosmetic studies cannot be turned into the claim that this ingredient causes no reactions.

## Has any study compared niacinamide, hyaluronic acid and panthenol side by side?

No. Studies that put hyaluronic acid up against other moisturizing ingredients such as glycerin, ceramides or petrolatum came only from patients with skin conditions, patients with skin exposed to radiation, and burn patients, not from people with healthy skin, and the sources contain no human study that pitted panthenol against niacinamide. So claims such as "niacinamide beats a hyaluronic acid serum," or the reverse, are not something research has confirmed.

If you change the question, some parts become answerable. Instead of "which ingredient is better?", ask "how many ingredients in my routine already target the same kind of reading?" and "does the serum I want to buy list these three ingredients on their own or blended in?" Those you can check against the label and the maker's directions. These questions are gathered in the criteria table below.

![Two empty circles drawn in pencil on white paper, with a pencil beside them, on a wooden desk by a window](https://thetroublenote.com/images/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured-2.jpg)
*The sources for this article include no human trial that compared the three ingredients within one trial on healthy skin.*

## Panthenol and niacinamide in one product: how do you read those studies?

Even when panthenol and niacinamide come in one bottle, a study of that product cannot sort out which ingredient did what. A study published in 2026 had 35 adults with dry, sensitive skin (31 women, average age 47.3) apply a product with panthenol, niacinamide and dipotassium glycyrrhizate to one shin twice a day for 28 days, and compared it with the other leg, which got no product at all. Stratum corneum hydration and transepidermal water loss got better on the leg that received the product, but the authors themselves stated that without a vehicle control lacking the actives, the effect could not be credited to the active ingredients. The readings came from the legs, so they cannot be read as results for the face either.

A 2010 study randomly assigned 246 Indian women aged 30–60 to a facial lotion with niacinamide, panthenol and tocopheryl acetate or to a control lotion, comparing them double-blind for 10 weeks, and 207 took part to the end. This, too, was a finished product with the three ingredients mixed together, so each ingredient's share cannot be separated, and the most common adverse event reported was a brief, mild burning feeling, though its frequency was not given as a number. Neither study was designed to confirm that the effects of the two ingredients add up.

## Niacinamide vs hyaluronic acid vs panthenol: study skin and readings compared

When you line up what skin each set of studies looked at and what it measured, the three ingredients do not stand on the same line.

| Ingredient | Skin and people mostly studied | Main readings | Not in this article's evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hyaluronic acid (applied to skin) | Small trials in healthy adults (mostly 20–80 people), many with blended finished products or special formulations | Skin hydration readings | A sizable trial of hyaluronic acid alone at a normal level for over three months · differences by skin type or humidity · direct comparison with other moisturizing ingredients on healthy skin |
| Panthenol (dexpanthenol) | Skin irritated on purpose, skin after procedures, skin of people using medicines; many blended finished products | Hydration, transepidermal water loss and redness on damaged skin | A long trial of panthenol alone against placebo on healthy skin · differences by level (1, 2, 5%) |
| Niacinamide | Single-ingredient trials at 2–5%, a few dozen people, 4–12 weeks, plus a majority of studies using blended products or run alongside prescription medicines or procedures | A range of readings, including barrier-related ones such as water loss (TEWL) | Comparison with hyaluronic acid or panthenol under the same conditions · splitting each ingredient's share in blended studies |
| A product with both ingredients | Shins of 35 people with dry, sensitive skin (28 days) · faces of 246 Indian women (10 weeks) | Hydration, transepidermal water loss / adverse event reports | Each ingredient's share · whether the two ingredients' effects add up |

This table tells you two things. The three ingredients were studied on different skin with different readings, and studies of products holding more than one of them cannot split out each ingredient's share. No row supports the conclusion that one serum is better for your routine or that using all three is better.

![Side view of a woman in her late 20s in front of a bathroom mirror in the morning, lightly cupping both cheeks with her hands](https://thetroublenote.com/images/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured-3.jpg)
*Studies of products with more than one of these ingredients cannot split each one's share, so bringing in new products one at a time is what lets you tell reactions apart.*

## Should you buy another serum? A criteria table

Since research cannot rank them, what to check before buying is your own labels and the maker's directions.

| Criterion | What to look at | Where to check |
|---|---|---|
| Which of the three ingredients is listed | Whether niacinamide, hyaluronic acid (sodium hyaluronate and others) or panthenol appears in the full ingredient list of the new serum and of what you use now, and whether it is the single main ingredient or one of many | The product page or the full ingredient list on the container |
| How many same-role ingredients you already have | How many times ingredients studied for moisture readings already show up across the products in your routine | A note listing the full ingredients of your products side by side |
| Texture and the maker's use step | Whether it is a serum or a cream, and at which step the maker says to use it | The directions on the product page |
| Before-use notes | Whether it contains fragrance, ethanol or acids, and whether it says to avoid the eye area or skin that has not closed over | The product page's before-use section or the cautions on the container |
| Order of adding | Whether you add new products one at a time, only after checking how you reacted to the last one | Your own use log |

The first two rows settle "should I buy it?", and the other three settle "if I buy it, how do I bring it in?" If the same-role ingredient already appears in several products, research cannot explain what a new serum would add. If you are bringing in an ingredient you do not have, you need a stretch in which that one product is the only change, so you can tell whether a change came from it.

## When to see a dermatologist

- If you notice reactions listed in the product cautions, such as red spots, swelling or itching, after applying a new serum or cream, stop that product and see a dermatologist.
- If stinging when you apply it lasts beyond two weeks, have a doctor look for the cause instead of trying to sort out the ingredients yourself.
- If you are using a prescription medicine, ask the clinic that prescribed it before you add a new serum.

## Frequently asked questions

### I have dry skin. Should I use a hyaluronic acid serum or a niacinamide serum, or do I need both?

Research gives no basis for picking one of the two just because your skin is dry. Studies that applied hyaluronic acid mostly looked at skin hydration readings, niacinamide studies took several readings including water loss, and we found no human trial that tested the two serums against each other under the same conditions. To decide on both, first check whether the products you already use list the same ingredient, then add any new serum one at a time and watch how your skin responds.

### What is the difference between niacinamide and hyaluronic acid in skincare?

The two differ first in what their studies mostly measured. For hyaluronic acid applied to the skin, small human trials have repeatedly reported higher hydration readings. For niacinamide, single-ingredient trials at 2–5% and studies of blended products took several readings, including barrier-related ones. Because no human study has put the two head to head, all we can say is that they were studied differently, not that one is better.

### How should I read a cream that contains both dexpanthenol and niacinamide?

Having both ingredients in one cream is a fact about the ingredient list, not evidence that their effects add up. A 2026 study that had 35 people apply a product with both to one shin for 28 days had no vehicle control, so it could not tell which ingredient did what, and a 2010 study that compared lotions over 10 weeks also used a finished product with several ingredients mixed together. On the cream's label, read the two ingredient names together with before-use notes about fragrance or acids.

### Is niacinamide only for oily skin and pores?

There is no basis for splitting it that way. Trials that applied niacinamide on its own involved a range of people, mostly a few dozen at a time over 4–12 weeks, and there is also a study in which 35 people with dry, sensitive skin applied a product that combined it with panthenol. But we found no study that compared results by skin type, such as oily versus dry, so there is no data on which type it suits better.

### Panthenol or niacinamide: how do I choose just one?

No human study has compared the two directly, so research cannot pick one for you. Most panthenol evidence comes from damaged skin and from products that mix it with other ingredients, while single-ingredient niacinamide studies were mostly done at 2–5%. When choosing, check whether the ingredient is listed on its own or as one of many, and whether before-use notes about fragrance, ethanol or acids fit your skin.

### I already use a toner, a cream and an ointment. Can I add a serum or ampoule?

Before adding one, check the full ingredient lists of what you use now for the same ingredient as the new serum. With no study comparing the three ingredients side by side, there is no evidence that adding a serum makes things better, and if you change several products at once it is hard to pin down the cause of any reaction. If the ointment you use is a prescription medicine, ask the clinic that prescribed it before you add a serum.

### Can you use niacinamide and panthenol together?

The sources reviewed here include no study that checked how well the two go together. There are studies of products that hold panthenol and niacinamide in one formula, but their design could not separate each ingredient's share, and no study looked at layering two separately bought products. If you want to use both, start with one product, and add the other only after your skin shows no reaction, so you can later tell which one you reacted to.

### Is panthenol good for oily skin?

Results from testing panthenol only on oily skin are not within the sources reviewed here. Most panthenol studies took hydration and water-loss readings on skin that was deliberately irritated or damaged by procedures or medicines, so those results cannot be stretched to healthy oily skin. The conclusion of the US Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) is also only a safety assessment at current use levels, so if you have oily skin, look at the panthenol listing along with the texture and the before-use notes.

## Sources

- [Efficacy of a Topical Formulation on Skin Hydration and Barrier Function in Individuals With Xerosis: A 28-Day Randomized, Split-Leg, Untreated-Controlled Trial (2026, PMID 42108609)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42108609/) — A
- [The effects of a daily facial lotion containing vitamins B3 and E and provitamin B5 on the facial skin of Indian women: a randomized, double-blind trial (2010, PMID 20061726)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20061726/) — A
- [Efficacy of dexpanthenol in skin protection against irritation: a double-blind, placebo-controlled study (2003, PMID 14641355)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14641355/) — A
- [Randomized, double-blinded, vehicle-controlled, split-face study to evaluate the effects of topical application of a Gold Silk Sericin/Niacinamide/Signaline complex on biophysical parameters related to skin ageing (2015, PMID 25940759)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25940759/) — A
- [CIR — Safety Assessment of Hyaluronates as Used in Cosmetics (Final Report, 2023)](https://www.cir-safety.org/sites/default/files/FR_Hyaluronates_062023.pdf) — Institutional
- [CIR — Safety Assessment of Panthenol, Pantothenic Acid, and Derivatives as Used in Cosmetics (2017)](https://www.cir-safety.org/sites/default/files/panthenol_0.pdf) — Institutional

## Product information related to this article

Product information from the site operator (KW Cosmetic, maker of the SKIN9HARI brand).

**Revive Therapy N.F Toner** — ₩29,000 (KRW)

Whether to buy another serum comes down to the label's single-or-blended listing, the same-role ingredients you already use, the use step and the before-use notes. Read that way, this toner lists niacinamide 2.0% (the maker's disclosed amount) among many other ingredients, so it is a blended product. None of the studies in this article tested this toner, and there is no data comparing it with hyaluronic acid or panthenol. Its product page places it after cleansing and before moisturizer. It contains ethanol 3.0%, salicylic acid and fragrance, so watch how your skin responds when you pair it with acid products. For the step of checking labels first, the product we suggest is Revive Therapy N.F Toner.

- Mildly acidic toner (pH 5.5–6.5), 150 ml
- Contains niacinamide 2.0% and beta-glucan 1.0%
- Low-irritation formula
- Contains ethanol and fragrance ingredients (orange peel oil, lavender oil); check the full ingredient list

### Product details

- **Type and size**: Clear, water-light toner, pH 5.5–6.5, 150 mL (5.07 fl oz)
- **Step in routine**: Step 2 of 4 · Tone, right after cleansing
- **How to use**: After cleansing, pour a small amount onto a cotton pad or your palms. Sweep or press gently over your face and neck. Pat lightly until fully absorbed. Follow with Revive Therapy N.F Ampoule, then N.F Cream.
- **Before you use**: Contains ethanol (3.0%) and fragrance, including the allergens linalool and limonene — this is not an alcohol-free formula. If redness, swelling or itching occurs, stop using and consult a dermatologist.

_Based on the official product page, checked 2026-10-02_

[View in shop](https://skin9hari.co.kr/en/shop/)

Cosmetics do not diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Test results apply only to the stated conditions.

---

TroubleNote is run by KW Cosmetic Content Team. Articles on this site are general information and do not replace diagnosis or medical care. If your symptoms are severe or last a long time, consider seeing a dermatologist.

Written by KW Cosmetic Content Team · Last updated 2026-11-20 · https://thetroublenote.com/en/compare/niacinamide-vs-hyaluronic-acid-panthenol-serum-what-studies-measured/
